An Updated Exempt Application form to Reduce Burden: Changelog
As part of our ongoing review of our forms and materials, we overhauled the Exempt Application Form to be easier to complete. The changes reflect feedback and recommendations from researchers who use the form.
Why we made these changes
Researchers told us the form took too long to complete and some questions were hard to interpret. Reviewers saw issues come up repeatedly in submissions. Especially around missing details on compensation and secondary data, unclear data security plans, confusion over the options for anonymized/coded/identifiable data, and uncertainty about what to do when recruiting one’s own students or employees. The new form asks simple studies fewer questions and explains what we need where we most often ask for revisions. It also reflects recent changes to NU policy and our guidance.
Changes include:
Protocol and Investigator Information
- Protocol and funding information are combined into one section. Unfunded studies now check a box instead of entering “NU.”
- PI eligibility checkboxes and the department field are removed, replaced by a link to the Policy on Principal Investigator Eligibility.
- The student section has a shorter oversight question.
- Dual appointments are now one question for the whole study team, replacing the separate PI and student questions. The question focuses on affiliations relevant to the research, with clear guidance on when you need to coordinate with another institution.
- The question about non-NU collaborators is easier to follow and is paired with the new guidance document described below.
Research Locations
- The narrative about each location is replaced by a checkbox confirming you’ll obtain any required permissions. The confirmation also covers the terms of service for online groups and platforms.
- The international research question is simplified.
Participant Information
- Inclusion and exclusion criteria sections better explains that the criteria can be listed instead of written as a narrative.
- Age ranges and enrollment goals are removed. A new note explains that most exemption categories don’t apply to minors.
Recruitment
- Streamlined option for simple studies: studies that recruit only through public postings or online recruitment panels can skip most of the section.
- Easier frameworks for recruiting people you know. The question now starts with a simple Yes/No, so most studies can skip ahead. If you plan to recruit your own students, employees, colleagues, etc., the form asks whether a power differential exists and suggests common strategies as checkboxes, which will make it easier to include these populations in your research. It also links to our relevant guidance.
Study Procedures
- New method options that reflect some gaps: photovoice, member checking, and written reflections or journals.
- Revamped description of what is needed for the procedures narrative.
Participant Information Sheet
- Rephrased to better explain the expectation that participants must prospectively agree before any research procedures, including data collection, begin.
- Clearer Yes/No options on whether all activities are disclosed.
Compensation
- Rephrased to explicitly cover non-monetary compensation, such as subject pool credit and extra credit.
- Spells out exactly what we need: amount, method, timing, schedule, pro-rating, and raffle odds. Links to our compensation guidance.
Existing Data
- Better explain that it needs to be used when using existing data to identify potential participants for recruitment.
- Rephrased to spell out what we need about the dataset, including whether it contains identifiers. Data dictionaries or codebooks are optional.
Risks
- Privacy and confidentiality risks moved to the Confidentiality section, so they’re addressed only once.
- Prompts that weren’t essential to exempt review are removed.
Confidentiality and Privacy
- Streamlined option for simple studies: studies that collect no identifiers can skip the entire section by checking a box.
- The identifiers list is clarified with examples such as IP addresses and student ID numbers. It now better explains that it includes identifiers collected for compensation.
- Clearer options, definitions, and frameworks for coded and anonymized data, plus a new option for contact information that’s never linked to research data.
- Simplified coding questions, with a checkbox confirming codes aren’t based on participant information.
- Data security is now a checkbox confirming you comply with NU Policy 702 and the Data Classification Guidelines. Studies using only NU-approved platforms need just one checkbox instead of a written description of what platforms are used.
- New checkbox option for securely storing paper materials on NU premises.
- Retention and destruction are now a single confirmation checkbox.
- New privacy protection options on monitored email accounts and keeping sensitive details out of messages.
Documents and Attachments
- Updated submission checklist to reflect new forms.
We will continue to accept the previous form, but we strongly encourage using the new one. We hope it makes it easier for you to submit a study that meets exemption requirements.